Homepage      A to Z Index    Book outline    People      Places       Plays       About these letters      About EJ Phillips      Chronology      EJ Phillips Facebook Fan Page 

John Nickinson's New York City 1837-1850 and beyond

John Nickinson's New York City Google map        Charles Dickens       Edgar Allan Poe

John Nickinson and his first wife Mary Anne Talbot Nickinson had five children – daughters Charlotte (1832-1910), Eliza (1834-1917), Virginia (1838-1899), Isabella (1847-1906) and son John Jr. (1844-1916),. Charlotte and Eliza were born in Quebec, while John was still in the British army in Canada, and Virginia was born in Albany shortly after he left the army to become an actor.  John Jr and Isabella were born in New York City. 

After Albany (1836-37) the family came to New York, where John Nickinson played  at the Franklin and Park Theatres, then to William Mitchell's Olympic from 1841-1850, until it closed abruptly. While the Nickinsons were in New York City they spent winters there and summers on tour in Canada. John Nickinson's later success in Toronto seems due to his contacts, particularly with James Wallack,  and knowledge of theatre in New York.  He produced plays which had recently been seen there, invited friends and colleagues to perform in Toronto and brought a new level of sophistication to Toronto dramatics. 

What influence did the Panic of 1837 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panic_of_1837 https://dp.la/primary-source-sets/the-panic-of-1837  have on the Nickinson family fortunes? Banks failed, unemployment increased, and despite a brief recovery in 1838 the depression continued for about seven years.

. William Mitchell's Olympic Theatre 422 Broadway  1837-1854      William Mitchell as Crummles  Palmo's later Chamber's |                                                                                                                                                                                    Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=4193159
                                                                                                                                                       
  Niblo's Garden 1828       Niblo's Theatre   Astor Opera House 1850 Flomian - 
                                                                                                                                                                                                        

The Temple of Momus: Mitchell's Olympic Theatre  by David Rinear, gives a good idea of the New York City the Nickinsons knew on their arrival.  "several smaller playhouses opened and closed in the city with dazzling rapidity during the 1820s and 1830s, but by the autumn of 1837 the only theatres which were operating on a continuing basis during the winter months were the Park, Bowery, National, the much smaller and even less significant Franklin, and the soon-to-be opened Olympic." Summer theater began in 1828 when restauranteur William Niblo established Niblo's Garden and by the late 1830s built a permanent theatre (but did not become a year round company for many years.) The Olympic was half the size of the Park, Bowery and National.  The building was based on Madame Vestris' Olympic in London, and programs there as well "The entertainment will consist of the lighter varieties of the drama, combined with opera, vaudeville, and ballet, as at Madame Vestris' London Olympic." "While the fashionable members of New York society were making the Olympic dress circle and boxes a place in which to be seen, the opposite end of the socioeconomic spectrum was busily making the pit their particular province. ..Mitchell's pit became the favorite haunt for the newsboys butcherboys and apprentices known collectively to that day and age as the "b'hoys".... The better class of people went to the Park and the rude mechanicals and "riff-raff" attended the Bowery. But everyone went to the Olympic."...John Nickinson joined the Olympic in the fall of 1841 "and rapidly became a favorite".

Between 1836 and 1842 the annual number of Irish immigrants increased from 12,645 to 51,542... This piqued curiosity about Ireland and all things Irish, providing a favorable environment in which Tyrone Power and others established an audience.  But Power drowned in 1841 and George Mossop, a minor comedian specializing in Irishmen left the Olympic after the first season.  However John Nickinson "expressed a desire to learn the business of Irish characters and Mitchell encouraged him to work on several of the standard Irish vehicles.  Nickinson appeared in his first Irish piece The Happy Man on 10 January 1842 and proved to be extremely popular in this, appearing in it twenty times during that season... Yet Nickinson was not exclusively or even primarily a specialist, he was called upon to play support to Mitchell in other farces, extravaganzas and burlesques more often than he played his newly developed line of business.

Mitchell's greatest success of the [1842] season was a burlesque of Richard III entitled Richard #3 a conflict over who was to be the new driver of omnibus #3.  Mitchell played Richard  eventually the omnibus driver, while John Nickinson played Henry King "an old omnibus driver" and Richard's predecessor. This play ran for twenty nine consecutive evenings. The next attraction was Cinderella with a duet sung by Edwin and Nickinson which was "loudly encored, Nickinson "lost the key sang in one different from that which was played by the orchestra." The audience found this hilarious, and even the hapless Nickinson finally gave up and joined in the general laughter.  The Albion's critic found the incident, "a good joke -- for once-- but it must not be repeated." Although the critic was inclined to forgive Nickinson's vocal mistake, he found some of the contents of the new extravaganza in questionable taste. ...and the offended critic grudgingly admitted, "We may truly consider the piece a decided hit."  David Rinear, Temple of Momus

video of staged reading of John Wilkes Booth's Richard III in 2016 https://boothiebarn.com/2016/02/02/tonight-john-wilkes-booths-richard-iii/  2018 https://boothiebarn.com/2016/02/02/tonight-john-wilkes-booths-richard-iii/

Charles Walcot, whose son Charles Jr was to marry Isabella Nickinson, joined Mitchell's Olympic in September 1842. In 1843 Jan 23-Feb 7 John Nickinson was in Beauty and the Beast: Comic Operatic and Melo-dramatic Fairy Extravaganza at Mitchell's Olympic Theatre, with Charles Walcot playing the Beast, and Mrs. Mossop (later Mrs John Drew and mother=-in-law of Maurice Barrymore) as Marygolda. Women Writers Dramatized 2000 https://books.google.com/books?id=3n1msu2y1WgC&dq=inauthor:%22H.+Philip+Bolton%22&source=gbs_navlinks_s

MacBeth Travetie by WK Northall was first produced at New York's Olympic Theatre with John Nickinson as First Witch Oct 16, 1843 and William Mitchell as MacBeth and Mrs Booth as Lady MacBeth.  Script with stage business, cast of characters, relative positions, etc.  https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=uc2.ark:/13960/t4sj1k366;view=1up;seq=14https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=uc2.ark:/13960/t4sj1k366;view=1up;seq=14

Both Nickinson and Walcot -- "two of Mitchell's most popular and useful actors: left the Olympic in 1847. John Nickinson went to the Park theatre. The Park burned on 16 Dec 1848 but John Nickinson had rejoined the Olympic in September 1848.

John Nickinson's greatest part was Havresac in Boucicault's  The Old Guard, which he acted from 1848-52 in the Olympic Theatre, New York. He and Charlotte (playing Melanie to his Havresack) toured in this for three years. Described in Joseph Norton Ireland's Records of the New York Stage from 1750-1860 (vol. II June 24 1846) Niblo's Garden -- The first time the interesting and exciting drama entitled Napoleon's Old Guard ... It was triumphantly successful and continued being played nightly ... The Vauxhall Garden Saloon was opened on the first of June 1846 with Mr. BA Baker as stage manager and Henry Chapman, Nickinson, Miss [Charlotte] Nickinson [and others] as performers...The youthful and pretty Miss Nickinson made her first appearance as Rose in "Cousin Lambkin" and Clarissa in "Bothered Between 'Em".  She was exceedingly neat and clever in juvenile walking ladies and a year or two later was warmly applauded as the representative of Florence Dombey at Burton's Theatre.  Charlotte Nickinson joined the Olympic in 1846"although Miss Nickinson was but a teenager and had no professional experience, she rapidly became one of the Olympic audiences' favorite performers."

John Nickinson Castle Garden June 1848 George Holland manager, Charlotte also in company    June 1846 Vauxhall Gardens "an unusually brilliant company". Nickinson played Alderman Lollipop in Cinderella March 7 1842.  Dombey in Dombey and Sons at Burtons 1848  August 16 and Charlotte Nickinson as Florence.  Sept 1850 John and Charlotte Nickinson in the company of the Astor Place Opera House. Planche's admirable interlude  "Lavater the Physiognomist was played for the first time in new York on the 8th of May. Lavater was one of Nickinson's favorite parts, but his personation has since been surpassed in excellence by Mr. Walcot and Mr. C Mathew

One source says John Nickinson's last appearance in New York was in May 1862 at Laura Keene's  Ireland's History of the New York Stage says he appeared for the first time in ten years as Havresack with Isabella Nickinson playing Melanie, and he played Spurrit in The Post Boy in June.  Charles Peters and Owen and Virginia Nickinson Marlowe were in Laura Keene's company that season.  But I have a playbill (a gift from Effingham Dolman) in which he was playing in Harlem  Aug. 20 1862 in The Soldier's Return;' Or an Unwarrantable Intrusion as Old Potter, with Owen Marlowe, singing St. Patrick's Birth--day and concluding with the farce of Box, Cox, and Knox; or The Printer and the Hatter as Box with Marlowe as Cox. Marlowe and Isabella Nickinson were also in the Household Fairy! as Julian De Clifford and Katharine.  

Did John Nickinson ever meet Edgar Allan Poe? 

A reminiscent article of peculiar interest, written by one who knew Poe intimately in his latter days, appeared in the New York Times, in 1888 [Memories of Edgar A. Poe, Fordham still treasures his odd old cottage, Aug. 12, 1888] “Poe had his offs and ons, declares this chronicler. “He was not a steady drinker. Appreciation was his thirst. Often he found it in the society of intellectual women, who visited himself and wife in the city. Ordinarily grave and silent among them he could be chatty and witty. Craving excitement apart from his labor, he sought the companionship of his guild downtown, and he found that, too, in a little store  in Nassau Street, between Ann and Beekman, where gathered a few elevated literary minds, reinforced by a sprinkling of actors like Peter Cunningham, John Brougham, Oliver Raymond, Tom Johnston and John Nickinson  It was not a dramshop, but it dispensed various kinds of nervine, and it had facilities for adding emphasis to what ‘the Governor of North Carolina once said to the Governor of South Carolina.’    Clara Dargan Maclean, “Some Memorials of Edgar Allan Poe,” Frank Leslie’s Popular Monthly, April 1891, vol. XXXI, no. 4, pp. 457-464 http://www.eapoe.org/papers/misc1851/18910401.htm 

IT’S a long time between drinks!” Everybody knows that’s what the governor of North Carolina said to the governor of South Carolina. But who knows, for sure, which governor said it, to whom it was addressed, or when and where and under what circumstances it was uttered?  Cambridge Sentinel, Volume XXXIII, Number 23, 4 June 1938  https://cambridge.dlconsulting.com/cgi-bin/cambridge?a=d&d=Sentinel19380604-01.2.9

Where did the Nickinson's live in New York?
Nickinson John comedian  42 Hamersley  The New York City Directory ..., Volume 2 (Google eBook)  C.R. Rode, late Doggett & Rode., 1843 - New York (N.Y.) [Hammersley is [now West Houston St.]  http://forgotten-ny.com/1999/09/greenwich-village-necrology/
Longworth's American Almanac, New York Register, and City Directory ...
 (Google eBook) T. Longworth & Son., 1841 https://books.google.com/books?id=kjREAQAAMAAJ&vq=nickinson&source=gbs_navlinks_s also
also lists John Nickinson as living at 42 Hamersley

Later city directories list John Nickinson as living at 5 Crosby St in Soho. . (1845, 1846, 1848)
97 Crosby Street is about four blocks away from 5 Crosby. http://daytoninmanhattan.blogspot.com/2018/03/edward-judsons-1895-97-crosby-street.html In the 1840s the block of Crosby Street between Prince and Spring Street was still upscale.  Commodious brick houses built in the 1820's and '30's were still occupied by well-to-do families....But the respectability of the neighborhood would erode by the time of the Civil War.  

John Nickinson and Mary Anne Talbot Nickinson legally separated in March 1855 in Toronto, because "unhappy differences have arisen and do still subsist". Mrs Nickinson and Isabella seem to have gone to New York in early 1858.  Mary Ann Talbot Nickinson's death March 13 1877 was reported in the New York Herald as being at the home of her daughter Mrs. C Peters.  A funeral mass was celebrated at St Lawrence's Roman Catholic Church at 84th and Park avenue. A number of John Nickinson's first family's children also  ended up in New York.

After Mitchell's Olympic Theatre in New York closed abruptly in 1850, John Nickinson formed his own company and with daughter Charlotte toured in Providence RI, Montreal, and Rochester and ended up in Toronto in 1851.  Charlotte spent most of the rest of her life in Toronto, although Daniel Morrison worked for the New York Times and they lived in New York City briefly.

John Nickinson and Charles Dickens
Dickens wrote about New York theaters in  American Notes for General Circulation " There are three principal theatres.  Two of them, the Park and the Bowery, are large, elegant, and handsome buildings, and are, I grieve to write it, generally deserted.  The third, the Olympic, is a tiny show-box for vaudevilles and burlesques.  It is singularly well conducted by Mr. Mitchell, a comic actor of great quiet humour and originality, who is well remembered and esteemed by London playgoers.  I am happy to report of this deserving gentleman, that his benches are usually well filled, and that his theatre rings with merriment every night.  I had almost forgotten a small summer theatre, called Niblo’s, with gardens and open air amusements attached; but I believe it is not exempt from the general depression under which Theatrical Property, or what is humorously called by that name, unfortunately labours.

American Notes was originally published in October 1842.  John Nickinson was in New York when Dickens visited in 1842.  As reported in Record of the New York Stag e " The 19th of February [1842] is memorable from the performance of the "Love Chase," with Nickinson as Fondlove, Hieldi as Waller, Gates as Wildrake, Mrs. Stickney as Widow Green, and Mrs. Shaw as Constance, being honored by the attendance of Charles Dickens. "

The Dickens Boz Ball Feb 14 1842 was at the Park Theatre.  Dickens did many reading during his second  1867 US trip, but I don't know that he did any in 1842.

Dickens 1867 trip to America was a series of readings, and Lauren Hutton reported in Players and Plays published in 1875 about Dickens' reading of Dombey and Son.  John Brougham's version of Dombey and Son "took the town by storm" and "Burton's fortune as an actor and manager were made."  John and Charlotte Nickinson played Dombey and Florence Dombey and Oliver B Raymond's Toots "was so thoroughly Toots "that the Toots of Dickens himself, when he read Dombey to us here was a woeful disappointment"  "Mr Nickinson and his daughter\, whom we remember as the best Havresack and Melanie in "The Old Guard" of their day. Lately from Mitchell's Olympic they added strength to Burton's  company and their Dombey and Florence were perfect gems of acting."


I went to New York in October 2016 for a party at the Joseph Pulitzer  Mansion on East 73rd St, at the invitation of Swarthmore friend Phil Davies, director of the Eccles Centre for American Studies at the British Library. I went the next day to the New York Public Library for the Performing Arts at Lincoln Center, and found the following newspaper clipping in great-great grandfather’s John Nickinson file.


New York Season Nov 26 1870 (newspaper unidentified)
This article was published over six years after Nickinson’s death, and twenty years after his regular appearances in the city. It recalls the illustrious career of John Nickinson and how sad it is that Nickinson is buried in Cincinnati, when he had so many people remembering him with great affection in New York.

“Nickinson spoke French well and imparted just enough of its accent to his British English in the role to give it the fullest expression of its nationality. Then too Nickinson had been a soldier and had that peculiar bearing which comes of thorough drill in a regular army.  There is one other part of Nickinson’s acting that always had great fascination for me. It used to be given about Christmas time, a dramaturgy by Walcott of one of Dickens’s Christmas stories. “The Haunted Man”. Nickinson played the old father. I have never seen such extreme old age so touchingly portrayed, in words whose awe was mingled indescribably with a most human pathos pray “Lord keep my memory green”. I have heard Dickens read the story, but never felt its beauty and power so forcibly as when Nickinson uttered these words with his trembling arms, laden with the red berried holly and dark Christmas ivy. Dickens read it, but Nickinson looked as the one who thought it.” A.R.C.


John Nickinson (1808-1864) died at 57 so he had limited experience of extreme old age. Actor Charles M. Walcott is credited as the author of the play The Haunted Man. His son Charles Melton Walcott Jr married Isabella Nickinson in 1863. John Nickinson and Charles Walcott played together at the Olympic Theatre in New York in 1842 and in Toronto in 1852.


Charles Dickens, The Haunted Man and the Ghost’s Bargain, 1848 https://en.wikipedia.org/…/The_Haunted_Man_and_the_Ghost's_…

full text https://archive.org/stream/hauntedmanthegho00dickuoft…

 This is the fifth and final Dickens’ Christmas story. A Christmas Carol was published in 1843. 
Illustrations for the Haunted Man, Victorian web http://www.victorianweb.org/art/illustration/haunted/pva75.html



Bibliography
Dickens, Charles American notes for General Circulation, 1842 https://www.gutenberg.org/files/675/675-h/675-h.htm
Dickens, Charles Dombey and Son https://www.gutenberg.org/files/821/821-h/821-h.htm  Haven't found a script for John Brougham's version of Dombey acted by John and Charlotte Nickinson. 
Charles Walcot also produced a less successful version.
Dickens, Charles  Haunted Man https://archive.org/stream/hauntedmanthegho00dickuoft

"Dickens in America"  BBC DVDs have actress and Dickens enthusiast Miriam Margoyles retracing the 1842 trip https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dickens_in_America  
 Have watched the New England and New York pieces and look forward viewing the rest. 

 
John Nickinson's children also lived in New York as adults

Owen Marlowe, who married Virginia Nickinson,  was with Laura Keene in New York 1861-1862, and in 1863-1867 with Mrs. John Drew's company in Philadelphia. in 1868 he was in San Francisco under the management of John McCullough. In June 1870 five Marlowes were living in New York, according to that year's census -- Owen, Virginia, Jesse, Ethel and Virginia.  By June 1871 Owen Marlowe was back in San Francisco, and by January 1872 Virginia Marlowe was appearing there in plays with him. However by July 1873 Owen Marlowe was given a farewell benefit with a rosewood cane given by the Bohemian Club and went east by steamer through Panama.  No mention in the newspapers when Virginia returned east. By  Sept 1984 Owen Marlowe was appearing in Brooklyn in London Assurance. In  1874 he visited his family in England for the first time in 20 years, and in  1875 appeared in New York as Phileas Fogg in Around the World in Eighty Days, in "18 spectacular scenes:...from his London club room through the Suez into the interior of a Hindoo bungalow ...[leading] up to a "startling pyre" and a Grand Funeral Pageant."  [Bordman, Gerald: American Musical Theatre: A Chronicle 2010]. In March 1876 he was appearing in Chelsea Massachusetts in Our Boys and died in May at Mass General Hospital of consumption.  He died penniless and was buried in Forest Hills Cemetery, Boston.  Virginia was appearing in Toronto at her sister Charlotte Morrison's Grand Opera House as the boy Paul in The Octoroon.

Their daughter Ethel Marlowe died in 1898, suddenly of heart trouble, at the Knickerbocker Theatre, in the third act of The Christian. Virginia's  New York Clipper obituary (Mar. 18, 1899) reported that she had retired from the stage "at the time of her daughter's sudden death" and had since made her home with the married daughter, at whose house she died.

A 1905 article in Donohoe's magazine interviewed Mrs. Charles Peters [Eliza Nickinson]  and said she had become a Catholic under the instruction of Jesuit Father Damen, while living in Yorkville New York. She went back to acting after the death of her husband and played a New England widow and Irishwoman in the 1870s and played similar roles in Boucicault's Shaughraun, various roles in the Irish village at the St, Louis World's Fair and the part of the Widow McNally in the Sunshine of Paradise Alley was written for her. She talks about going to the old St. Patricks School on Mulberry St .but when the sisters learned that the girls were the daughters of an actor they were promptly sent home.   http://books.google.com/books?id=qgjZAAAAMAAJ&vq=nickinson&dq=eliza+nickinson+peters&source=gbs_navlinks_s

Son John Nickinson Jr.  (c. 1844-Feb 1916) according to a brief New York Times (Feb. 15, 1916) obituary, was "for many years managing clerk at the grocery division of the Appraiser's Stores" and died suddenly at work at 72, leaving a daughter in Toronto.  He had entered the Customs Service in 1881. An 1886 New York City Directory listed him as a clerk with an address at 221 East 81st. St.

John Nickinson Jr. seems to have been involved with theatrical publishing.  
Project Gutenberg Punchinello project notes that applications for advertising should be addressed to John Nickinson, Room No. 4, No. 83 Nassau St. N. Y. [between John and Fulton St. according to Google Maps t.]  
Punchinello Vol. 1. No. 3 http://www.fullbooks.com/Punchinello-Vol-1-No-3-April-16-1870.html 
Vol. 1 No. 7 http://www.fullbooks.com/Punchinello-Vol-1-No-7-May-14-1870.html 
Vol. 1 No. 19http://www.gutenberg.org/dirs/1/0/0/1/10015/10015-h/10015-h.htm 
Vol. 2 No. 32http://www.gutenberg.org/dirs/1/0/1/0/10104/10104-h/10104-h.htm 

Isabella Nickinson's  last appearance in Toronto seems to have been on Jan. 11, 1858 at the Royal Lyceum in The Wife, playing Florabella.  

She appeared on the stage in New York at Laura Keene's Theatre in May 1862 as Melanie to John Nickinson's Havresack.  She married the actor Charles Melton Walcot Jr. (1840-1921) in 1863 in New York and played with him at the Walnut Street Theatre in Philadelphia.  They then joined Daniel Frohmans' company in New York and appeared at the Lyceum Theatre from 1887-1899. Until her death they almost always played together. History of the American Stage  Isabella was part of Laura Keene's company in 1862 and in November appeared as Uria in Blondette or the Naughty Prince and the Pretty Peasant. In April 1863 she was Pennie Durgan in Bantry Bay or Ireland in 1798 with Charles Peters as Phadrig.   in 1894 she appeared in Henry Arthur Jones' Case of the Rebellious Susan and in 1895 in Oscar Wilde's An Ideal Husband.

Blanche Whiffen (the original Buttercup of HMS Pinafore) writes in her autobiography of being friends with Isabella Walcot.  "Once, when we were rehearing [David Belasco Henry DeMille's]  "The Charity Ball," Mrs. Walcot and I, thinking we had time enough, went out to seek some lunch while a scene just before outs was being rehearsed. As luck would have it, our scene was called while we were away, and when we came back, Mr. Belasco was very angry and called us down, ending up with: "And from now on you won't go out to lunch at all. You'll  stay in the theatre and eat beans and drink water!"  Mrs. Walcot, being a braver soul than I , spoke up pertly:" "All right, Mr. Belasco! I'll bring the beans if you bring the water!" And she did bring a pot of Boston baked beans the next morning, Mr. Belasco took the joke and helped us eat the beans, bringing us a large dipper of water.  Mrs. Thomas Whiffen, Keeping off the Shelf, New York EP Dutton & Co, 1928 The Charity Ball opened Nov 1, 1889 at the Lyceum Theatre and also had Herbert Kelcey, WJ LeMoyne, and Charles Walcot in the cast, closing the season on May 26 1890 after 200 performances, according to the History of the New York Stage.

Players of the Present, John Bouvé Clapp, 1899 has several paragraphs on Isabella Nickinson Walcot and her career and a photo. http://books.google.com/books?id=QhsPAAAAIAAJ&dq=nickinson&q=nickinson#v=snippet&q=nickinson&f=false
Both Walcots were in the Booth brothers production of Julius Caesar  with Edwin as Brutus, Junius Brutus as Cassius,  John Wilks as Mark Antony, and Charles Walcot as Octavius and Isabella as Calphurnia. After the Winter Garden Theater burned the Walcots went to the Walnut St Theatre in Philadelphia for about 12 years, and joined Daniel Frohman's stock company in 1887.
Walcot is noted (in Durham)as a member of the Madison Square Company in 1884-1885,  where EJ Phillips had been since 1877. His father was also an actor, "an eccentric comedian and writer of burlesques" who had been at Mitchell's Olympic Theatre with John Nickinson.  The son "sported a moustache and always wore the jovial expression of a genial English squire."  Dictionary of American Biography



Isabella Walcot's NY Times obituary (June 4, 1906) refers to her "memorable run of 100 nights at the Old Winter Garden in Broadway, opposite Bond Street, [where] she played Ophelia to
 [Edwin] Booth's Hamlet" and says that she was "for forty years a familiar and loved figure on the stage." She died at her home 200 West 101st St., three months after a stroke at their country home in Rhinebeck. Her last stage engagement had been with Annie Russell.

Her NY Dramatic Mirror obituary June 9 1906 says she was born in New York City Oct 7 1847. Her "earliest recorded appearance was as Melanie in Napoleon's Old Guard, her father acting the part of Havresack.
Under the able direction of Laura Keene she received a thorough old fashioned training, playing leading juvenile characters in the Keene company."

More on Virginia, Eliza and Isabella's roles available in A history of the Thomas Allston Brown's  New York Stage Volume 2 1851-1901  
http://books.google.com/books?id=mJEXAAAAYAAJ&dq=nickinson+fanchon&source=gbs_navlinks_s 

Ireland's  Records of the New York Stage 1750-1860  has a number of references to John and Charlotte Nickinson
 http://books.google.com/books?id=C6INAAAAQAAJ&vq=nickinson&source=gbs_navlinks_s

Bibliography
Rinear, David, Stage, Page Scandals and Vandals: William E Burton and 19th century American Theatre, Southern Illinois Univ Press, 2004 https://www.amazon.com/Stage-Page-Scandals-Vandals-Nineteenth-Century/dp/0809325721
Rinear, David, The Temple of Momus: Mitchell's Olympic Theater, Scarecrow Press, 1987

New York City Mayors 2010 has a list of New York Theaters https://books.google.com/books?id=mNe7Sph7lJ8C&dq=new+york+city+chatham+st+1837&source=gbs_navlinks_s

Demolished New York Theaters http://www.musicals101.com/bwaypast.htm

Timeline New York City 19th century https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_New_York_City#19th_century
The population of New York City from the June 1840 census was 312,710. The US population had increased by 32.7% from the 1830 census. By the 1850 census New York's population was 515,547.

Last revised Oct. 14,  2018

            
year month day notes1 city theatre play events   2018 march 18 notes 2 age source
1836 9 8   New York NY Bowery Theatre John Nickinson leaves Montreal for an engagement in New York                hist Montreal
1837 2 3   New York NY Franklin Theatre Monsieur Tonson JN first appeared in NY in Monsieur Morbleau by Wm T Moncrieff's                rec NY stage   
1837 7 24   New York NY Franklin Theatre Pickwick Club John Nickinson as Pickwick             29 rec NY stage   
1837 10 9 New York NY Franklin Theatre Geoffrey Dale JN as the miser's man Jacob Codling     Hutton NY clipper 1878
1838 1 1   New York NY Mitchell's Olympic Richard III JN as Catesby I & Lewey Madigan in Erin go bragh or a tale of Munster                 Hist NY Stage
1840 1 10 New York NY Mitchell's Olympic Happy Man JN in first Irish piece at the Olympic   performed 20 times in season 31 Momus rec NY stage
1840 9 4   New York NY Park Theatre How to pay the rent JN with Tyrone Power                rec NY stage
1840 9 30   New York NY Park Theatre King Lear John Nickinson as Burgundy             32 rec NY stage   
1841 0     New York NY City directory lists JN as comedian living at 42 Hamersley [West Houston St]               NY City Directory
1841 2 1 ? New York NY Park Theatre Money John Nickinson in Bulwer Lytton's  Money               Odell
1841 4 24   New York NY Park Theatre Jack Cade JN as Friar Lacy with Edwin Forrest in Robert T Conrad's Jack Cade or Aylmere           premiere   life Edwin Forrest Odell
1842 2 10   New York NY Mitchell's Olympic Richard III burlesque JN as King Henry in                Hist NY Stage
1842 3 7   New York NY Mitchell's Olympic Cinderella JN as Alderman Lollipop in Cinderella or the Foreign Prince & a Large Glass Slipper           Charles Walcott   hist NY stage NY Clipper 1/26/1889 
1842 5 18   New York NY Mitchell's Olympic White Horse of the Peppers  JN as Croaker in Samuel Lover's          Petty Sins & Pretty Sinners JN  Reuben Snaffler   hist am stage
1842 11 7   New York NY Mitchell's Olympic   Don Giovanni in Gotham JN Mons Kickba   Clipper1889 Feb 2 34 NY clipper
1842 12 26   New York NY Mitchell's Olympic   Captain of the watch by Planche JN Baron Vanderpotter   Hutton Players
1843 0     New York NY City directory lists JN as comedian living at 42 Hamersley [West Houston St]               NY City Directory
1843 1 23 to Feb 7 New York NY Mitchell's Olympic Beauty & the beast JN as Croton Pump in Planche's Beauty & the Beast               NY Clipper 1889
1843 9 13 New York NY Mitchell's Olympic Charles Walcot Sr and George Holland join Mitchell's Olympic       NY Clipper Momus
1843 10 3 New York NY Mitchell's Olympic Hamlet Travestie JN Polonius     1843-44 Salary $15/week Momus 35 NY herald loc
1843 10   New York NY Mitchell's Olympic   MacBeth by Northall JN as first witch Mrs JB Booth [debar] as Lady Macbeth       Hutton Players
1843 11 7   New York NY Mitchell's Olympic Don Giovanni in Gotham JN as Mons Kickshaw in Chas Walcot's Don Giovanni in Gotham          3-4 other roles/plays in article   NY Clipper 2/2/1889
1844 0   circa New York NY John Nickinson Jr born            JN 34 Mary Ann 36 0 estimate 
1844 1 8   New York NY Mitchell's Olympic Old King Cole John Nickinson as Old King Cole               rec NY stage   
1844 2 8   New York NY Mitchell's Olympic   Devil n Paris JN Walcot Holland Debar Fenno very effective acting in   Anglo American
1844 6 . to Sept New York NY Niblo's Garden John Nickinson in    Parson's Nose La Fille du Regiment     36 ?
1845 0     New York NY Napoleon's Old Guard print   JN and Charlotte 60 printed 37 Phelps NY state library
1845 2 3   New York NY Mitchells Olympic   Devil in Paris JN Mr Debar Mr. Walcot Mr Holland     Hutton Players
1845 5     New York NY Bowery Theatre principal members of company transferred to including Nickinson Chanfrau               rec NY stage   
1845 6 1   New York NY Niblo's Garden Seven castles of the passions John Nickinson as Mephistopheles               rec NY stage   
1845 7 13 2 weeks New York NY Niblo's Garden Honeymoon John Nickinson with Mrs. Mowat, EL Davenport            Mem History City of NY   Cur Am Stage
1845 9 .   New York NY Mitchell's Olympic Charlotte Nickinson joins Mitchells Olympic         13 Shortt
1845 9 .. New York NY Niblo's Garden JN leaves Mitchell's Olympic for Park Theater Chas Walcot Sr  leave NY to tour       Momus
1846 0     New York NY John Nickinson comedian 5 Crosby            Soho also 1845   NY City Directory
1846 0   summer? New York NY Niblo's Garden Napoleon's Old Guard John Nickinson as Havresack in Boucicault's                ?
1846 4 12   New York NY Bombastes Furioso Ensign Nickinson  Major Genl Striker                Punch  
1846 6 1   New York NY Vauxhall Garden Bothered between JN performer Charlotte's NY Debut as Rose in Cousin Lambkin & Clarissa in Bothered Between Em             14 Rec NY Stage Hist NY Stage
1846 6 8   New York NY Vauxhall Garden Captain of the Regiment JN as Martelle in Captain of the Regiment               Rec NY Stage
1846 10 10   New York NY Mitchells Olympic John Nickinson at                   Anglo American
1847 4 17   New York NY Burtons Theatre Love and Murder John Nickinson as Senor Basta  in John Baldwin Buckstone's              38 Rec NY Stage
1847 10 7   New York NY Isabella Nickinson born           JN 39 Mary Ann 41 0 players clapp
1848 0     New York NY John Nickinson comedian 5 Crosby            also 1847     NY City Directory
1848 2 24 ?? New York NY Mitchell's Olympic King of the Peacocks Isabella in             1 Odell
1848 5 8   New York NY Burtons Theatre Lavater the Physiognomist John Nickinson in James Robinson Planche's                rec NY stage
1848 6 5   New York NY Castle Garden Castle Garden re-opened Geo Holland, JN Charlotte             40 NY Clipper
1848 6 24   New York NY Castle Garden Old honesty new farce Holland Nickinson Mrs. Vernon Miss N Monson               Gazette of the Union
1848 8 16   New York NY Burtons Theatre Dombey & Sons CN Florence Dombey JN orig Dombey  by John Brougham' also stage mgr Burtons              CN 16 Hist NY Stage Players Albany
1848 10   New York NY Mitchell's Olympic Who's got Macready or a Race to Boston JN as Macready   Momus
1848 12 18   New York NY Amphion Love's Telegraph JN as Baron Pumpernickel   Odell
1849 5 10 New York NY Astor Opera House Astor Place riot   were Nickinson in NYC?   Wikipedia
1849 9 10   New York NY Mitchell's Olympic Brittania & Hibernia with Eliza John Jr Isabella Nickinson           Eliza 15 John Jr Isabella 2 rec NY stage Shortt
1850 0 ?   New York NY Burton's Theatre John Nickinson at Burton's Theatre                rec NY stage   
1850 0   New York NY John Nickinson comedian 5 Crosby Eliza Nickinson embroidery         NY City Directory
1850 3 9   New York NY Mitchell's Olympic Olympic closed abruptly               Hartnoll Oxford Companion
1850 5 13   New York NY Niblo's Garden Home John Nickinson as Squre Bullworthy by John Brougham               Record NY
1850 9 20   New York NY Italian Opera house John Nickinson   Italian Opera House Astor Place     42 Odell?
1850 10 ?   New York NY Niblo's Garden Charles Peters came to America Fall 1849, first engaged Niblo's            Charles 25 hist am stage
1851 10 1 to 4 New York NY Poetus Caecinna Charlottes final NY appearance in Isaac Clarke Pray's tragedy Poetus        Clarke Prays tragedy   DCB Odell
1852 5 23   New York NY Olympic? How to pay the rent JN Last appearance in New York until 1862                Odell
1855 1   11 New York NY Eliza Nickinson married Charles Peters moves to NY           Chas 29 20 NY Herald Marriages deaths
1855 9 . brief New York NY Barnum's Museum Owen Marlowe first on stage as Lamp in Wild Oats          then southern & western theatre 25 Winter Brief Chronicles
1857 9 28   New York NY Laura Keenes Siam Light Guard with Mrs Chas Peters as Dodo and Chas Peters as Knappkin                
1858 2   ? New York NY Isabella and Mary Ann Nickinson go to New York           Mary Ann 52 IN 10 Shortt
1858 6 New York NY Laura Keenes Napoleon's Old Guard Isabella Nickinson 1st appeared at Laura Keenes as Melanie       HAS
1858 10   to 1859 march New York NY Laura Keenes Our American Cousin Charles Peters original Binney by Tom Taylor              22 histrionic Montreal
1859 12 to Mar 1860 New York NY Winter Garden Octoroon Dion Boucicault Agnes Robertson Jos Jefferson    Wikipedia etc
1861 9 16 to Dec late New York NY Laura Keenes Seven Sons Owen Marlowe Fred Flutter  Mrs Marlowe Sulfurus             31 Hist NY Stage
1861 12 27   New York NY Laura Keenes Dickens Christmas with Peters Marlowe           Laura Keene
1862 0 ? to 1863 New York NY Laura Keenes Isabella Nickinson,  Chas Walcot leading man, Charles Peters Mr and Mrs. Owen Marlowe at Laura Keene's               Life of Laura Keene
1862 0 ?   New York NY Laura Keenes Rivals Peg Woffington Isabella Nickinson as Mabel Vane in Peg Woffington Julia Melville The Rivals                players clapp
1862 2 9   New York NY Laura Keenes Fair one with the golden locks Isabella Nickinson as Papil in JR Planche's                Odell
1862 2 10 New York NY Laura Keenes Our American Cousin Owen Marlowe Sir Edw Trenchard Mrs Marlowe Sharpe         Laura Keene
1862 5 16   New York NY Laura Keenes Sea of Ice Owen Marlowe Geo de Lavel Mrs Marlowe Countess de Theringe  Chas Peters               Laura Keene
1862 5 21   New York NY Laura Keenes JN and daughter to perform at benefit Mr. Peters       NY clipper
1862 5 29   New York NY Laura Keenes Old Guard JN Havresack Isabella Melanie               Hist NY Stage
1862 6 2   New York NY Laura Keenes Post Boy John Nickinson as Spurritt               Hist NY Stage
1862 6 14   New York NY Winter Garden Wizards Tempest Prof  Anderson reopens with Messrs Nickinson and others in The Wizard's Tempest or the King of the Magical Island             54 NY Clipper
1862 8 20   New York NY Washington Hall Harlem Household fairy JN as Box Mr. Marlowe as Cox in John Madison Morton's Household Fairy                playbill
1862 8 20   New York NY Washington Hall Harlem Soldier's return or an unwarrantable intrusion          Owen Marlowe Isabella Nickinson   playbill
1862 9 2   New York NY Laura Keenes Old Heads and Young Hearts Isabella Nickinson Chas Peters Owen Marlowe               Laura Keene
1862 9 9 New York NY Laura Keenes Laura Keenes stock Co Owen Marlowe Isabella Nickinson JH Stoddart Stuart Robson MM Chas Peters   15 Laura Keene
1862 9 19   New York NY Laura Keenes Laura Keenes stock Co Owen Marlowe Isabella Nickinson JH Stoddart Stuart Robson MM Chas Peters               Laura Keene
1862 9 26   New York NY Laura Keenes School for Scandal Isabella Nickinson Maria Owen Marlowe Carless JH & MRS Stoddart               Laura Keene
1863 3 23   New York NY Laura Keenes Jessy McLane Isabella Nickinson as Mrs Gimp         with Chas Peters Chas Walcot Laura Keene   Hist NY Stage
1863 4 6   New York NY Laura Keenes Bantry Bay .Isabella Nickinson in Bantry Bay or Ireland in 1798 as Penny Durgan with Chas Peters               Clapp players
1863 4 16   New York NY Laura Keenes Rivals Isabella Nickinson as Julia Stuart Robson Bob Acres CM Walcot Capt Also Laura keene Lydia Languish     Players Present
1863 5 4   New York NY Laura Keenes Tib or our cat in crinoline Isabella Nickinson burlesque               Hist NY Stage
1863 5 31   New York NY Isabella Nickinson married Charles M Walcot Jr             16 Clapp players
1863 7 3   New York NY Draft riots in NY and elsewhere         civil war
1863 10 8   New York NY Mrs J Woods Olympic Isabella and Charles Walcot at Mrs. J Woods Olympic Theatre               Hist NY Stage
1863 10 20   New York NY Laura Keenes No rest for the wicked Owen Marlowe Castelle Chas Peters JH Stoddart               Hist NY Stage
1863 11 25 1862? New York NY Laura Keenes Blondette Isabella Nickinson in Blondette The Naughty Prince as Una               Hist NY Stage
1864 11 16 to Mar 65 New York NY Old Winter Garden Hamlet Isabella Walcot plays Ophelia to Edwin Booth's Hamlet by Shakespeare   100 night run             17 players clapp
1864 11 25   New York NY Winter Garden Julius Caesar Walcots play Cassius & Calphurnia with Edwin, Junius Brutus Jr & John Wilkes Booth               players clapp
1864 12 8   New York NY Napoleon's Old Guard Benefit for Charles Peters run over by a 3rd Ave car  C  Walcot $4k raised             30 Hist NY Stage
1864 12 8   New York NY Acad of music School for Scandal Isabella Walcott as Maria               Hist NY Stage
1867 3 23   New York NY Winter Garden Winter Garden burns so Walcots move to Walnut st Theatre Philadelphia             20 players clapp
1868 2 25 New York NY Mitchells Olympic Fanchon Maggie Mitchell Owen Marlowe as Didier         .
1869 0   New York NY John Nickinson clerk 1812 Third Ave       25 NY City Directory
1869 3 15   New York NY Wallacks Theatre School for Scandal Owen Marlowe Sir Benj also J Wallack JH Stoddart EM Holland               Hist NY Stage
1869 5 3   New York NY Wallacks Theatre Caste Owen Marlowe Captain Hawtree          1st US performance play   Hist NY Stage
1870 0   to 1871 New York NY JN Jr Mercantile Library Association Board of Directors               NYT
1870 1 25   New York NY 14th St Theatre Lady of Lyon Owen Marlowe Glavia     benefit for George Holland 39 Hist NY Stage
1870 1 28 to Apr 6 New York NY Wallacks Theatre Lost at Sea Owen Marlowe Lord Alfred Colebrooke bu Boucicault and Byron               Hist NY Stage
1870 4   to Nov New York NY John Nickinson Jr theatrical publishing             26 Punchinello
1870 6 1 New York NY Owen Marlowe Va Marlowe Jesse 8 Virginia 5 Ethel 2     OM 40 VN 32 CENSUS US 1870
1870 11 2   New York NY Charles Peters died     son Fred daughter Maud 36 NY Clipper
1870 11 28   New York NY Sllemania Hall Owen Marlowe readings just returned from California               Hist NY Stage
1871 4 15   New York NY Laura Keenes Rivals Owen Marlowe Sir Anthony Absolute              40 NY clipper
1871 6 8   New York NY Acad of music Colleen Bawn Owen Marlowe as Kyrle Daly               Hist NY Stage
1871 6 26   New York NY 14th St Theatre Pretty piece of business Mr Mrs Chas Walcot benefit for Owen Marlowe               Hist NY Stage
1874 5 4 to May 9 New York NY Lyceum? School for Scandal Owen Marlowe Sir Benjamin               Hist NY Stage
1874 11 10   New York NY Grand Opera House A Flash of Lightning Mrs CM Walcot as Bessie       Augustin Daly?          by Augustin Daly 27 Hist NY Stage
1877 0   ? New York NY Mary Ann Talbot Nickinson died?             71 ancestry?
1877 1 19   New York NY Park Theatre Colonel Sellers Mrs. Charles Peters in Mark Twain's Colonel Sellers              41 NY Clipper
                             
             
                             
               
                             
                           
                             
                             
                             
                             
                       
                             
             
                 
                       
                           
                             
                       
                           
                             
                             
                         
               
                             
                             
                             
                         
                             
           
                           
                             
                             
           
                             
             
                         
               
                             
                             
             
                             
                       
                             
                             
             
                           
                           
                       
                             
                           
                       
           
                             
                             
                           
             
                           
             
                             
                             
                       
                             
                   
                             
                             
                             
                             
                             
                     
                             
             
                             
                             
                             
                             
                       
                             
             
                             
                           
                 
                             
                             
                             
                             
                             
                           
                             
                             
                 
                             
                         
                           
                             
             
                         
                           
                           
               

Homepage  A to Z Index  Bibliography  People   Places   Plays   About these letters  About EJ Phillips   EJ Phillips Facebook Fan Page